The Criminalization of Pregnant Women -***please avoid plagiarism ***-I will attach the article that you need to read. More info: Please review The Crimina

The Criminalization of Pregnant Women -***please avoid plagiarism ***-I will attach the article that you need to read. More info: Please review The Criminalization of Pregnant Women. The article is attached in pdf format. After reviewing the article and conducting your own research, complete 1-2 paragraphs in which you: (a) Discuss the issue of criminalizing pregnant drug-addicted mothers, generally; (b) Explain whether you agree with the author’s position and why. ;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;;
The Criminalization of
Pregnant Women and
the Illusion of MaternalFetal Conflict
Kylie Alexandra
Sociology 324
IOUIFNJET UIFDSJNJOBMJ[BUJPOPGQSFHOBOUESVH
BEEJDUFEXPNFODBNFUPMJHIUBTBTJHOJëDBOUQSPTFDVUPSJBM
USFOE XJUIBOFNQIBTJTPODSBDLDPDBJOF )JSTDIFOCBVN
#FUXFFOBOE QSPTFDVUPSTDIBSHFENPSF
UIBOXPNFOXJUIUBLJOHESVHTXIJMFQSFHOBOU.BOZPG
UIFTFXPNFOTQFOUUJNFJOQSJTPOBTBSFTVMUPGUIFJSBSSFTU
BOETPNFMPTUDVTUPEZPGUIFJSDIJMESFO 5PTDBOP-JN
ɨFPêFOTFTSBOHFEGSPNEFMJWFSJOHESVHTUPBNJOPS
WJBUIFVNCJMJDBMDPSEUPDIJMEBCVTFBOEDIJMEFOEBOHFSNFOU
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO-JN “DDPSEJOH
UP/PSB4(VTUBWTTPO UIF8BSPO%SVHTBNPVOUFE
UPOPUIJOHNPSFUIBOBXBSPOXPNFO JOQBSUJDVMBS “GSJDBO
“NFSJDBOXPNFO
1SPTFDVUPSTDMPBLUIFJSFêPSUTUPDSJNJOBMJ[FXPNFO
XJUIOVNFSPVTQIJMPTPQIJDBMKVTUJëDBUJPOT6UJMJUBSJBOJTN
QSFTVQQPTFTUIBUMFHBMSFNFEJFTXJMMQSPUFDUUIFGFUVTGSPNIBSN
BOENPUJWBUFESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOUPTFFLUSFBUNFOUUIF
GBWPSFEPVUDPNFTKVTUJGZUIFQSPTFDVUPSJBMNFBOT -JN
5PTDBOP “SHVNFOUTGPSEFUFSSFODFBTTVNFUIBUESVH
BEEJDUFEXPNFOFOHBHFJOGSFFBOESBUJPOBMEFDJTJPONBLJOH
BOBMZTFTBOEUIBUGFBSPGQSPTFDVUJPOXJMMUJQUIFTDBMFTJO
GBWPSPGESVHBCTUFOUJPO*ODPOUSBTU -JTB&DLFOXJMFS
TVDDJODUMZTVHHFTUTUIBUiLFFOBUUFOUJPOUPUIFQBSUJDVMBSTPG
UIFTFXPNFOTMJWFTSFWFBMTUIBUGSFFEPNJTOPUBGVMMZSFBMJ[FE
JEFBMw Q 7JDLJ5PTDBOP ESBXTUIFEJTUJODUJPO
UIBUSFUSJCVUJWFKVTUJëDBUJPOTBQQMZOPUKVTUUPUIFGPSNPG
TFOUFODJOHJNQPTFEPODPOWJDUFEXPNFO CVUBMTPUPUIF
FêFDUTUIFTFOUFODJOHIBTPOQVCMJDEJTDPVSTFDPODFSOJOH
QSFHOBOUXPNFOTSFTQPOTJCJMJUJFTUPXBSEUIFJSVOCPSOCBCZ
$SJNJOBMJ[BUJPOUSBOTGPSNTBNPSBMSFTQPOTJCJMJUZJOUPBMFHBM
SFTQPOTJCJMJUZBOEQSPNPUFTUIFJEFBUIBUQSFHOBOUXPNFOXIP
UBLFESVHTIBWFBCBOEPOFEUIJTSFTQPOTJCJMJUZ BSFJOUFOUJPOBMMZ
JOìJDUJOHIBSNPOUIFJSVOCPSOCBCZ BOEEFTFSWFQVOJTINFOU
5PTDBOP
ɨFBUUFNQUTUPSBUJPOBMJ[FQSPTFDVUJPOFNQIBTJ[FIPX
DSJNJOBMJ[BUJPOìPVSJTIFTXJUIJOBOFNFSHFOUTPDJBMEJTDPVSTF
UIBUDPODFQUVBMJ[FTNBUFSOBMBOEGFUBMSJHIUTJODPOìJDU
$SJNJOBMJ[JOHQSFHOBOUXPNFODIBSBDUFSJ[FTNPUIFSTBTiBHFOUT
PGIBSNwBOEDPOTJEFSTUIFJOUFSFTUTPGUIFGFUVTTFQBSBUFUP
UIPTFPGUIFNPUIFS (VTUBWTTPO ɨFCFMJFGJO
NPUIFSBOEGFUVTBTTFQBSBUFFOUJUJFTSFQSFTFOUTBDSJUJDBMFMFNFOU
JOUIFBCJMJUZPGQSPTFDVUPSTUPDIBSHFBOEDPOWJDUXPNFOGPS
DSJNFTBHBJOTUUIFJSVOCPSODIJME
ɨFTPDJBMDPOTUSVDUJPOPGNBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUFêFDUJWFMZ
JOEJWJEVBMJ[FTXPNFOTSFTQPOTJCJMJUZGPSQSPEVDJOHIFBMUIZ
CBCJFTBOEJHOPSFTTUSVDUVSBMQSPCMFNTUIBUJOGSJOHFVQPOUIFJS
BCJMJUZUPEPTP &DLFOXJMFS ɨJTEJTDPVSTFQSPEVDFT
BWBSJFUZPGOFHBUJWFPVUDPNFTGPSCPUINPUIFSTBOECBCJFT
3FTFBSDIJOEJDBUFTUIBUQSPTFDVUJPOTEJTDPVSBHFQSFHOBOU
XPNFOGSPNTFFLJOHUSFBUNFOUGPSUIFJSBEEJDUJPOBOEQSFOBUBM
DBSF (VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO5PTDBOP
.PSFPWFS GFBSPGQSPTFDVUJPOSFQSFTFOUTBNPUJWBUJOHGPSDFGPS
ESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOUPDPOTFOUUPTUFSJMJ[BUJPO -JN
*OQFSIBQTUIFNPTUTUSJLJOHFYBNQMFPGCFMJFGJONBUFSOBM
GFUBMDPOìJDU BOPOQSPëUPSHBOJ[BUJPOOBNFE$IJMESFO
3FRVJSJOHB$BSJOH,PNNVOJUZ $3″$, FNFSHFEEVSJOHUIF
IFJHIUPGUIF8BSPO%SVHTJOUIFNJETBOEDPOUJOVFTUP
PêFSESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOVQPOQSPPGPGTUFSJMJ[BUJPO
#BTFEJO$BMJGPSOJB $3″$,DMBJNTDIBQUFSTBDSPTTUIF
NBJOMBOE6OJUFE4UBUFT $3″$, “MUIPVHIPTUFOTJCMZ
PêFSJOHDBTIUPCPUINFOBOEXPNFO UIFJSNPTUSFDFOUEBUB
JOEJDBUFUIBU$3″$,QBJEBUPUBMPGXPNFOJOSFUVSO
GPSTUFSJMJ[BUJPODPNQBSFEXJUINFO $3″$, “U
MFBTUQBSUPGUIFSFBTPOGPSUIJTEJTDSFQBODZDBOCFGPVOEJOUIF
QSPTFDVUPSJBMCJBTUPXBSETXPNFOBOEUIFMBDLPGBUUFOUJPO
QBJEUPUIFFêFDUTPGNBMFESVHUBLJOHPOUIFEFWFMPQJOHGFUVT
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO4PMPNPO5PTDBOP
.FOIBWFMJUUMFUPGFBSUIBUXPVMEDPOWJODFUIFNUP
QFSNBOFOUMZUSBEFUIFJSSFQSPEVDUJWFBCJMJUZGPSTVDIBQBMUSZ
TVNPGNPOFZ
ɨJTQBQFSSFWJFXTUIFNFEJBPCTFTTJPOBOERVFTUJPOBCMF
TDJFOUJëDMJUFSBUVSFUIBUVOEFSMJFTUIFQSPTFDVUPSJBMUSFOEPGUIF
QBTUUXPEFDBEFTBOEUIFDPODVSSFOUFTUBCMJTINFOUPGNBUFSOBM
GFUBMDPOìJDUɨFNBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUXJMMCFSFWFBMFEBT
BGBMTFEJDIPUPNZBOE$3″$,FYQPTFEBTNJTHVJEFEBOE
EJTDSJNJOBUPSJMZQVOJUJWF”QBSBEJHNTIJGUJTSFDPNNFOEFE
UPXBSETSFDPHOJUJPOPGUIFJOUSJOTJDBMMZTIBSFEJOUFSFTUTPG
NPUIFSBOECBCZBOEUIBUBCFUUFSBMUFSOBUJWFUPQSPTFDVUJPO
JOWPMWFTUIFSFBMMPDBUJPOPGSFTPVSDFTUPUSFBUNFOUQSPHSBNTBOE
QSFOBUBMIFBMUITFSWJDFT
ɨFQSPTFDVUJPOPGQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOJT
)0)0/67PMVNF
intimately connected with the manner in which the media
GSBNFEUIFSJTFJODSBDLDPDBJOF7BSJPVTNFEJBPVUMFUT
EFQJDUFEESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOBTQSPNJTDVPVTQSPTUJUVUFT
XIPTFDPOTVNQUJPOPGDSBDLEFTUSPZFEUIFJSNBUFSOBMJOTUJODU
XIJMFUIFZTJNVMUBOFPVTMZQSPEVDFENVMUJUVEFTPGTVCTUBODF
FYQPTFECBCJFT -JN3PCFSUT5PTDBOP
%PSPUIZ3PCFSUT IJHIMJHIUTIPXUIFNFEJBXPWFB
EJTQBSBHJOHTUFSFPUZQFPGCMBDLXPNFOJOUPUIFJSQPSUSBZBMPG
UIFDSBDLFQJEFNJDCZMJOLJOHJUXJUIIJHISBUFTPGCMBDLJOGBOU
NPSUBMJUZoEFTQJUFUIFGBDUUIBUIJHIJOGBOUNPSUBMJUZSBUFT
XFSFSFDPSEFEMPOHCFGPSFXJEFTQSFBEVTFPGDSBDL3BDJBM
CJBTFTDIBOOFMFECMBNFGPSBDPNQMFYTPDJBMQSPCMFNPOUPUIF
JOEJWJEVBMCBDLTPGQPPS”GSJDBO”NFSJDBOXPNFOXIPXFSF
QSPTFDVUFEBUBEJTQSPQPSUJPOBUFMZIJHISBUF 3PCFSUT
4PMPNPO
.FEJBBUUFOUJPOQSFTTVSFEUIFTDJFOUJëDMJUFSBUVSFUP
TVQQPSUUIFJEFBUIBUQSFOBUBMESVHFYQPTVSFSFQSFTFOUFE
BOVSHFOUQSPCMFNFWFOUIPVHIUIFFêFDUTPOJOGBOUTXFSF
OPUDPODMVTJWF 5PTDBOP /PSB(VTUBWTTPOBOE”OO
.BD&BDISPO SFWJFXFETUVEJFTUIBUBUUFNQUFEUP
BTDFSUBJOUIFJODJEFODFBOEQSFWBMFODFPGQSFOBUBMESVHFYQPTVSF
BOEGPVOEUIBUUIFSBUFTBSFVODMFBS.PTUSFTFBSDIXBT
DPOEVDUFEJOQVCMJDIPTQJUBMTUIBUBUUFOEUPQPPSBOENJOPSJUZ
XPNFO”TVSWFZPGVSCBOIPTQJUBMTJOSFQPSUFEBO
BWFSBHFQFSJOBUBMJMMJDJUESVHSBUFPG”‘MPSJEBTUVEZJO
BUUFNQUFEUPSFNPWFUIFDMBTTBOEFUIOJDCJBTGPVOEJO
QSJPSTUVEJFTBOEEJTDPWFSFEUIBUMJUUMFEJêFSFODFFYJTUTCFUXFFO
JMMJDJUESVHSBUFTGPSXIJUFBOECMBDLXPNFO (VTUBWTTPOBOE
.BD&BDISPO
$PNQPTJUFEBUBGSPNOVNFSPVTTUVEJFTTIPXUIBUo
PGJOGBOUTTVêFSGSPNQSFOBUBMDPDBJOFFYQPTVSFBOOVBMMZ
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO ɨFQSFDJTFDBVTBM
FêFDUTPGDPDBJOFPOUIFEFWFMPQJOHGFUVTBSFOPUDPODMVTJWFMZ
FTUBCMJTIFE #POPFUBM &BSMJFSTUVEJFTJOEJDBUFUIBU
DPDBJOFNBZDBVTFQSFNBUVSFCJSUI BTNBMMIFBEDJSDVNGFSFODF
BOEBCOPSNBMJUZPGUIFVSJOBSZUSBDU (VTUBWTTPOBOE
.BD&BDISPO “EEJUJPOBMSFTFBSDITVHHFTUTUIBUDPDBJOF
FYQPTFEJOGBOUTNBZTVêFSEJTQSPQPSUJPOBUFMZGSPNDFSUBJO
UZQFTPGTUSFTT TIPSUFOFEBUUFOUJPOTQBO BOETMJHIUQSPCMFNT
JOMBOHVBHFEFWFMPQNFOU #POPFUBM 4PNFTUVEJFTEP
OPUëOEBOZTJHOJëDBOUEJêFSFODFTCFUXFFOJOGBOUTFYQPTFE
to cocaine in uteroBOEUIPTFUIBUXFSFOPU (VTUBWTTPO
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO .PSFPWFS SBNQBOU
NFUIPEPMPHJDBMDPODFSOTJONBOZPGUIFFBSMZTUVEJFTJMMVTUSBUF
UIBUDBVUJPOJTXBSSBOUFEXIFOUSZJOHUPESBXDPODMVTJPOT
GPSFYBNQMF TUVEJFTEJEOPUDPOUSPMGPSDPOGPVOEJOH
FOWJSPONFOUBMGBDUPSTPSUIFQSFTFODFPGPUIFSESVHTJOUIF
QSFHOBOUXPNBOTTZTUFNBOEPGUFOSFMJFEPOTNBMM OPO
SFQSFTFOUBUJWFTBNQMFT (VTUBWTTPO(VTUBWTTPOBOE
.BD&BDISPO (VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO
40 – HOHONU Volume 8 2010
BTTFSUUIBUNVDIPGUIFSFTFBSDIQVCMJTIFEEVSJOHUIFIFJHIU
PGUIF8BSPO%SVHTTVQQPSUTQBSUJDVMBSQPMJUJDBMJEFPMPHJFTCZ
GPDVTJOHPOXPNFOTSPMFJOSFQSPEVDUJPOPOMZ4UVEJFTUIBUEJE
OPUFTUBCMJTIDPOOFDUJPOTCFUXFFONBUFSOBMQSFOBUBMESVHVTF
BOEQPPSGFUBMPVUDPNFTXFSFMFTTMJLFMZUPSFDFJWFQVCMJDBUJPO
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO5PTDBOP
3FDFOUSFTFBSDIJOEJDBUFTUIBUGFXJOGBOUIFBMUIQSPCMFNT
DBOCFDPOëEFOUMZBUUSJCVUFEUPQSFOBUBMDPDBJOFFYQPTVSF
#POPFUBM5PTDBOP 4ZTUFNJDJTTVFTTVDIBTMBDL
PGBDDFTTUPQSFOBUBMNFEJDBMDBSF JOBEFRVBUFIPVTJOH QPPS
OVUSJUJPO BOEQFSTJTUFOUQPWFSUZBêFDUQSFHOBODZPVUDPNFT
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO5PTDBOP *O
QBSUJDVMBS MJWJOHXJUINBMFQBSUOFSTUIBUBSFTVCTUBODFBCVTFST
PSWJPMFOU PSCPUI JTBQSFEJDUPSPGQPPSQSFHOBODZPVUDPNFT
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO “OBOBMZTJTPG
QFFSSFWJFXFETUVEJFTPOUIFUFSBUPHFOJDJNQBDUPGDPDBJOF
GPVOEOPDPODMVTJWFFWJEFODFGPSOFHBUJWFFêFDUTPOQIZTJDBM
PSDPHOJUJWFEFWFMPQNFOU #POPFUBM 4UVEJFTXIJDI
GPVOEPUIFSXJTFVTVBMMZJOEJDBUFNJOJNBMEBNBHFXIFO
FOWJSPONFOUBMGBDUPSTBSFDPOUSPMMFEGPS*OEFFE ,BUIFSJOF
&#POPFUBM SFQPSUUIBUDIBSBDUFSJTUJDTPGUIFIPNF
FOWJSPONFOUJNQBDUDPHOJUJWFEFWFMPQNFOUNPSFDPOTJTUFOUMZ
UIBOEPFTQSFOBUBMDPDBJOFFYQPTVSF
/POFUIFMFTT QSPTFDVUPSTSFMJFEPOUIFTQFDVMBUJWFSJTLT
PGQSFOBUBMESVHFYQPTVSFUPVTFBDPNCJOBUJPOPGDIJMEBCVTF
BOEESVHSFMBUFETUBUVUFTUPDSJNJOBMJ[FQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFE
XPNFO -JN “QQFMMBUFDPVSUTMBSHFMZPWFSUVSOFE
QSPTFDVUPSJBMBUUFNQUTCVUOPOFUIFMFTTMFHBMQSFDFEFODF
GPSDSJNJOBMJ[JOHQSFHOBOUXPNFOFYJTUT (VTUBWTTPOBOE
.BD&BDISPO-JN *OPOFPGUIFFBSMJFTUDBTFT
BUUFNQUFE B’MPSJEBDPVSUDPOWJDUFEBXPNBOPGEFMJWFSJOH
DPDBJOFUPBNJOPSWJBIFSVNCJMJDBMDPSEJNNFEJBUFMZBGUFS
CJSUIɨF’MPSJEB4VQSFNF$PVSUMBUFSPWFSUVSOFEUIFEFDJTJPO
CVUOPOFUIFMFTTJUQBWFEUIFXBZGPSGVUVSFQSPTFDVUJPOT
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO)JSTDIFOCBVN
*O$BMJGPSOJBQSPTFDVUPSTDIBSHFE1BNFMB3BF4UFXBSU
.POTPOXJUIDIJMEOFHMFDUGPSGBJMJOHUPGPMMPXIFSEPDUPST
PSEFSTUPSFGSBJOGSPNTNPLJOHNBSJKVBOBBOEIBWJOHTFYVBM
JOUFSDPVSTFXIJMFQSFHOBOU4IFXBTBSSFTUFEBGUFSIFSJOGBOU
TVêFSJOHGSPNCSBJOEBNBHF EJFEBHFETJYXFFLT 4PMPNPO
5PTDBOP /PUBCMZ QSPTFDVUPSTDIPTFOPUUPDIBSHF
IFSIVTCBOE FWFOUIPVHIIFQBSUJDJQBUFEJOUIFQSPTDSJCFE
BDUJWJUJFTBOEIBEBIJTUPSZPGWJPMFOUCFIBWJPS3FTVMUTGSPNB
NFEJDBMFYBNTVHHFTUFEUIBUQIZTJDBMBCVTFBHBJOTUUIFNPUIFS
QPUFOUJBMMZDBVTFEUIFCBCZTEFBUI 5PTDBOP 1SPTFDVUPST
FWFOUVBMMZESPQQFEUIFDIBSHFTCVUOPUCFGPSFUIFDBTFSFDFJWFE
XJEFTQSFBENFEJBQVCMJDJUZ 4PMPNPO
$PVSUTJO4PVUI$BSPMJOBBQQFBSFTQFDJBMMZXJMMJOHUP
DPOWJDUESVHBEEJDUFEQSFHOBOUXPNFO*O8IJUOFSW
4UBUF B4PVUI$BSPMJOBDPVSUDPOWJDUFE$PSOFMJB8IJUOFSPG
DSJNJOBMDIJMEOFHMFDUGPSDPOTVNJOHDPDBJOFEVSJOHQSFHOBODZ
XIFOUSBDFTPGUIFESVHXFSFGPVOEJOIFSJOGBOUTTZTUFN
FWFOUIPVHIUIFJOGBOUEJEOPUTVêFSBOZBQQBSFOUFêFDUT
)JSTDIFOCBVN5PTDBOP ɨF4PVUI$BSPMJOB
4VQSFNF$PVSUVQIFMEIFSFJHIUZFBSTFOUFODF 5PTDBOP
ɨFTBNFDPVSUVQIFME3FHJOB.D,OJHIUTDPOWJDUJPO
BOEUXFMWFZFBSTFOUFODFGPSIPNJDJEFCZDIJMEBCVTFBGUFS
QSPTFDVUPSTTVDDFTTGVMMZBSHVFEUIBUIFSDPDBJOFVTFEVSJOH
QSFHOBODZMFEUPUIFJOGBOUCFJOHTUJMMCPSO &DLFOXJMFS
ɨFSFJTTDBOUTVQQPSUJOUIFMJUFSBUVSFUPTVHHFTUUIBU
QSPTFDVUJOHQSFHOBOUXPNFOQSPNPUFTIFBMUIZGFUBMPVUDPNFT
*OBSFMBUFEBSHVNFOU (FPSHF4DIFEMFS DPOUFOETUIBU
TPDJFUZNBJOUBJOTUIFSJHIUUPGPSDFQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFE
XPNFOUPVOEFSHPBCPSUJPOT)JTVUJMJUBSJBOKVTUJëDBUJPO
BSHVFTUIBUUIFQFSDFJWFETPDJBMBOEFDPOPNJDDPTUTPGDBSJOHGPS
TVCTUBODFFYQPTFECBCJFTPVUXFJHIUIFCFOFëUT FWFOUIPVHI
IBSNGVMFêFDUTBSFGBSGSPNDFSUBJO$3″$,SFMJFTPOBTJNJMBS
BSHVNFOUUPTVHHFTUUIBUJUTQSPHSBNPGTUFSJMJ[BUJPOBMMFWJBUFT
TPDJBMDPTUTJODVSSFECZUBYQBZFSTUIBUXPVMEPUIFSXJTFCF
TQFOUPOUIFDBSFBOESBJTJOHPGDIJMESFOCPSOUPESVHBEEJDUFE
XPNFO $3″$, *OCPUIDBTFT UIFTPMVUJPOUPBTPDJBM
QSPCMFNJTTPVHIUCZSFHVMBUJOHXPNFOTSFQSPEVDUJPO 5PTDBOP
)PXFWFS NPSFUIBOUXPEFDBEFTPGQSPTFDVUJOH
QSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFOIBTOPUQSPEVDFEMPXFSSBUFTPG
ESVHVTFEVSJOHQSFHOBODZ -JN
*OGBDU UIFDSJNJOBMJ[BUJPOPGQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFE
XPNFOQSFDJQJUBUFTBDUJPOTUIBUBSFIBSNGVMUPCPUINPUIFS
BOECBCZ”KVEHFJOUIF%JTUSJDUPG$PMVNCJBTFOUFODFEB
DPDBJOFBEEJDUFEXPNBODPOWJDUFEPGGPSHFSZUPQSJTPOTPMFMZ
POUIFCBTJTPGIFSQSFHOBODZ BMMFHFEMZUPQSPUFDUIFSVOCPSO
GFUVT)JTNJTHVJEFESBUJPOBMFJHOPSFEFWJEFODFUIBUJMMJDJU
ESVHTBSFSBNQBOUJODPSSFDUJPOBMJOTUJUVUJPOTBOEUIBUSBUFTPG
NJTDBSSJBHFBSFGBSIJHIFSUIBOUIFOBUJPOBMBWFSBHF (VTUBWTTPO
(VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO &OEBOHFSJOH
XPNFOTIFBMUICZQMBDJOHUIFNJOQSJTPOFOEBOHFSTUIFGFUVT
JUGVSUIFSEJTDPVSBHFTPUIFSQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFO
GSPNTFFLJOHUIFIFBMUIDBSFBOEUSFBUNFOUUIBUJTWJUBMUPGFUBM
BOENBUFSOBMXFMMCFJOH (VTUBWTTPOBOE.BD&BDISPO
5PTDBOP ‘PMMPXJOHUIF4PVUI$BSPMJOB4VQSFNF$PVSUT
EFDJTJPOJO8IJUOFSW4UBUF MPDBMUSFBUNFOUDMJOJDTSFQPSUFE
TJHOJëDBOUMZMPXFSQSFHOBOUGFNBMFBENJTTJPOSBUFT 5PTDBOP

ɨFBUUFNQUUPTFQBSBUFNBUFSOBMBOEGFUBMJOUFSFTUTGPSUIF
QVSQPTFPGDSJNJOBMJ[JOHESVHVTFBOEQSPNPUJOHGFUBMXFMMCFJOH
JTDPVOUFSQSPEVDUJWF5PTDBOP ESBXTBUUFOUJPOUPUIF
DPOUSBEJDUJPOJOIFSFOUJONBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUUIFVOCPSO
GFUVTJTDPOTJEFSFEMFHBMMZTFQBSBUFGSPNUIFNPUIFSCVUJUJT
UIFEFQFOEBOUOBUVSFPGUIFSFMBUJPOTIJQCFUXFFOUIFUXPUIBU
JTVTFEUPKVTUJGZQSPTFDVUJPO$POTJEFSBUJPOPGUIFNVUVBM
JOUFSFTUTPGUIFNPUIFSBOEGFUVTXJMMSFTVMUJOCFUUFSQSFHOBODZ
PVUDPNFTBOEJTNPSFDPTUFêFDUJWFUIBOJODBSDFSBUJPO”TTJTUJOH
QSFHOBOUXPNFOUPDBSSZUIFJSJOGBOUTUPUFSNJTGBSMFTT
FYQFOTJWFUIBOQSPWJEJOHDBSFGPSBQSFNBUVSFCBCZ (VTUBWTTPO
BOE.BD&BDISPO ɨJTBQQSPBDISFDPHOJ[FTUIBUESVH
VTFBNPOHQSFHOBOUXPNFOXBSSBOUTBQVCMJDIFBMUISFTQPOTF
OPUBDSJNJOBMSFTQPOTFFTQFDJBMMZJOMJHIUPGUIFGBDUUIBUNBOZ
XPNFOTFMGNFEJDBUFUIFFêFDUTPGEFQSFTTJPOUISPVHIUIFVTF
PGJMMJDJUESVHT &DLFOXJMFS-FTUFS
“#SJUJTITUVEZDPOEVDUFEGSPNoQSPWJEFT
FWJEFODFGPSUIFTVDDFTTPGFODPVSBHJOHQSFOBUBMIFBMUIDBSF
BNPOHTUQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFO1SFHOBODZPVUDPNFT
TVDIBTCJSUIXFJHIU HFTUBUJPOBMQFSJPE BOECSFBTUGFFEJOH
SBUFTXFSFNFBTVSFEBOEGPVOEUPTVCTUBOUJBMMZJNQSPWFJODBTFT
XIFSFUIFNPUIFSSFDFJWFETVQQPSUGSPNBNJEXJGF -FHHBUF
1SFHOBOUNPUIFSTSFTQPOEFEUPUIFQFSTPOBMDBSFBOE
BTBSFTVMUXFSFNPSFDPNQMJBOUXJUIQSFOBUBMBEWJDF -FHHBUF
3FTVMUTTVDIBTUIFTFIJHIMJHIUUIFQPTJUJWFBHFODZESVH
BEEJDUFEXPNFOVTFUPMJNJUUIFIBSNGVMFêFDUTPGQSFOBUBM
ESVHFYQPTVSFBOEQSFTFOUBTUSPOHDBTFGPSiFNQPXFSJOH
XPNFOJOTUFBEPGQVOJTIJOHUIFNw &DLFOXJMFS
1SFHOBOUXPNFOBOEUIFJSDIJMESFOCFOFëUXIFOUIF
EJTUSJCVUJPOPGSFTPVSDFTSFDPHOJ[FTUIFNVUVBMJUZPGNBUFSOBM
GFUBMFYJTUFODF
$3″$,SBJTFTBOVNCFSPGTFSJPVTFUIJDBMDPODFSOT*U
TUSBUJëFTSFQSPEVDUJPOCZDMBTTJGZJOHUIFSFQSPEVDUJWFDBQBDJUZ
PGDFSUBJOHSPVQTPGXPNFOBTVOEFTJSBCMF PGUFOJOBSBDJBMMZ
CJBTFENBOOFS 3PCFSUT “QSPNJOFOURVPUFPOUIF
$3″$,XFCTJUFTJOHMFTPVU”GSJDBO”NFSJDBOTUPTVQQPSUUIF
PSHBOJ[BUJPO $3″$, ɨFEPMMBSWBMVFBTTJHOFEUP
DIJMECFBSJOHJNQMJDJUMZEFSPHBUFTTPNFXPNFOTSFQSPEVDUJWF
QPUFOUJBMBOESFJOGPSDFTBSFQSPEVDUJWFIJFSBSDIZ 3PCFSUT
*UBSUJëDJBMMZSFEVDFTDPNQMFYTPDJBMQSPCMFNTUP
SFQSPEVDUJWFDBQBDJUZJOTUFBEPGIJHIMJHIUJOHTZTUFNJDJTTVFT
JOXPNFOTESVHBEEJDUJPO BOEQFSQFUVBUFTUIFJEFBUIBU
XPNFODBOBOETIPVMECFIFMESFTQPOTJCMFGPSBNFMJPSBUJOH
BTPDJBMQSPCMFN -JN3PCFSUT4PMPNPO
5PTDBOP $3″$,SFJOGPSDFTUIFEJTDPVSTFUIBU
TVQQPSUTDSJNJOBMJ[BUJPOUISPVHIUIFJSDPOUSPWFSTJBMCJMM
CPBSEBEWFSUJTFNFOUTi1SFWFOU$IJME”CVTFyDBTI
GPSESVHBEEJDUTXIPQBSUJDJQBUFJOMPOHUFSNCJSUIDPOUSPMw
)JSTDIFOCBVN BOEDPOUJOVFTUIFIJTUPSJDUSFOE
PGNPOJUPSJOHXPNFOTTFYVBMBOESFQSPEVDUJWFCFIBWJPS
‘VOEBNFOUBMMZ $3″$,SFQSFTFOUTBOFYUSFNFGPSNPG
NBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUCZBDUJWFMZQSPNPUJOHUIFJEFBUIBU
DFSUBJOXPNFOTIPVMEQFSNBOFOUMZTVêFSUIFMPTTPGUIFJS
SFQSPEVDUJWFDBQBDJUZ
ɨFDSJNJOBMJ[BUJPOPGQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFO
QSPWJEFTUIFGFSUJMFTPJMOFDFTTBSZGPSQSPHSBNTMJLF$3″$,
UPFNFSHF8IJMFUIFSFBSFNBOZEJWJTJWFFMFNFOUTXJUIJOUIF
$3″$,QSPHSBN JUQPXFSGVMMZJMMVTUSBUFTUIFPQQSFTTJWFOBUVSF
HOHONU Volume 8 2010 – 41
PGUIFTFQBSBUJPOPGNBUFSOBMBOEGFUBMJOUFSFTUTJOEFFE BOZ
JOUFSFTUJONBUFSOBMXFMMCFJOHJTOPUJDFBCMZBCTFOU
ɨF”NFSJDBO1VCMJD)FBMUI”TTPDJBUJPO “1)” DIBSHFT
UIBU$3″$,SFMJFTVQPOVOTPVOEEBUBDPODFSOJOHUIFFêFDUTPG
QSFOBUBMDPDBJOFFYQPTVSFBOEJHOPSFTUIFGBSNPSFXJEFTQSFBE
JODJEFODFPGBMDPIPMFYQPTVSFJOJUTSBDJBMMZCJBTFEDBNQBJHO
UPTUFSJMJ[FXPNFO “1)” *OEPJOHTP JUWJPMBUFTCBTJD
IVNBOBOEDJWJMSJHIUTCZiBUUBDLJOHUIFSFQSPEVDUJWFDBQBDJUZ
PGXPNFOSBUIFSUIBOUIFDPOEJUJPOTPGPQQSFTTJPOVOEFS
XIJDIQPPSXPNFOMJWFw “1)” $3″$,EPFT
OPUQSPWJEFTPDJBMPSëOBODJBMTVQQPSUUPXPNFOUIBUTFFLESVH
USFBUNFOU#BSSZ-FTUFS TVHHFTUTUIBUUIFTPDJFUBMTUJHNB
BUUBDIFEUPESVHVTFJOIJCJUTUIFQSPWJTJPOPGUSFBUNFOUPQUJPOT
$3″$,SFJOGPSDFTUIJTTUJHNBXIJDIJTFTQFDJBMMZIBSNGVM
HJWFOUIFEFBSUIPGESVHUSFBUNFOUQSPHSBNTGPSQSFHOBOUESVH
BEEJDUFEXPNFOBOEUIFEJSFOFFEGPSBEEJUJPOBMSFTPVSDFT
*OBTVSWFZPGESVHUSFBUNFOUQSPHSBNTDPOEVDUFEJO
FYDMVEFEQSFHOBOUXPNFOFYDMVEFEXPNFOVOEFS
.FEJDBJEBOEGVMMZFYDMVEFEQSFHOBOUDPDBJOFBEEJDUFE
.FEJDBJEQBUJFOUTBMMDBUFHPSJFTPGXPNFOJOXIJDI$3″$,
DMJFOUTBSFMJLFMZUPGBMM )JSTDIFOCBVN4PMPNPO
4PDJBMQSPCMFNTBSFDPMMFDUJWFMZDSFBUFEBOEEFëOFEɨF
TPDJBMDPOTUSVDUJPOPGUIFNZUIPGUIFQFSQFUVBMMZQSFHOBOU
DSBDLBEEJDUFEXPNBOSFìFDUFEQVCMJDBOYJFUZBOEJNCVFE
JUTFMGJOUPUIFFBSMZTDJFOUJëDMJUFSBUVSF#PUIQSPWJEFEUIF
GPVOEBUJPOGPSDSJNJOBMJ[JOHQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUFEXPNFO
BOEGPSNFEUIFTDBêPMEJOHGPSUIFDPODFQUVBMJ[BUJPOPG
NBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDU1SPTFDVUPSTBSPVOEUIFDPVOUSZTFJ[FE
VQPOUIFJEFBPGNBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUUPIPMENPUIFST
TJOHVMBSMZSFTQPOTJCMFGPSOFHBUJWFQSFHOBODZPVUDPNFTPVU
PGUIFNJTUBLFOCFMJFGUIBUQVOJTIJOHNPUIFSTXPVMEIFSBME
CFUUFSPVUDPNFTGPSCBCJFT”MUIPVHIDPOWJDUJPOTIBWFCFFO
PWFSUVSOFEJONPTUTUBUFTXJUIUIFFYDFQUJPOPG4PVUI$BSPMJOB
UIJTIBTOPUUSBOTMBUFEJOUPBSFKFDUJPOPGUIFQIJMPTPQIJFT
VOEFSMZJOHDSJNJOBMJ[BUJPO 5PTDBOP
.BUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUSFQSFTFOUTBEBOHFSPVTJMMVTJPOUIBU
EFQJDUTNPUIFSTBTBHFOUTPGIBSNBOEJOIJCJUTUIPTFNPTUJO
OFFEPGQSFHOBODZDBSFGSPNTFFLJOHJU$3″$,SFJëFTUIJT
JMMVTJPOBOESFJOGPSDFTUIFTPDJBMEJTDPVSTFUIBUCMBNFTXPNFO
GPSUIFDPNQMFYTPDJBMQSPCMFNPGQSFHOBOUESVHBEEJDUJPO
ɨFJSXJMMJOHOFTTUPQBZXPNFOGPSTUFSJMJ[BUJPONBLFTJU
FBTJFSUPEFNPUFTVQQPSUGPSTFSWJDFTUIBUBTTJTUQSFHOBOUESVH
BEEJDUFEXPNFOTFSWJDFTUIBUBSFQSPWFOUPQSPNPUFIFBMUIZ
CBCJFT
“CFUUFSBMUFSOBUJWFJTUPSFDPHOJ[FUIBUXPNFOTESVHVTF
FWPMWFTJOSFTQPOTFUPBNZSJBEPGQFSTPOBMBOEFOWJSPONFOUBM
GBDUPST JODMVEJOHEFQSFTTJPO QIZTJDBMBOEFNPUJPOBMBCVTF
FOUSFODIFEQPWFSUZ BOEUIFDPODPNJUBOUBCTFODFPGBEFRVBUF
IPVTJOH OVUSJUJPO PSIFBMUIDBSF.PSFPWFS BMMPGUIFTFGBDUPST
DPOUSJCVUFUPQPPSQSFHOBODZPVUDPNFT”DLOPXMFEHJOHUIJT
42 – HOHONU Volume 8 2010
NFBOTUIBUTPDJFUZIBTBDPMMFDUJWFSFTQPOTJCJMJUZUPQSPWJEF
TFSWJDFTBJNFEUPXBSEIFBMUIZSFQSPEVDUJPO”CBOEPOJOHUIF
GBMTFIPPEPGNBUFSOBMGFUBMDPOìJDUJTBOFDFTTBSZTUFQJO…
Purchase answer to see full
attachment